Students have found themselves out of school in the small district of Buena Vista in Michigan. Unfortunately, the impromptu vacation in a district made up of mostly minority and low-income students had nothing to do with the up-and-coming summer vacation. Buena Vista students have found themselves without a school to go to because the district has run out of money. Now, teachers are without a job, income, or benefits, and students are left wondering whether they will be able to officially complete their current school year.
A Financial Emergency
According to , parents and students received almost no advance notice that schools in the district would be closing. On May 6, district officials decided to close the schools and lay off all the teachers in the midst of what they called a 鈥渇inancial emergency鈥 under Michigan law. A letter on the district website announced the district-wide closure to parents and students on the morning of May 7, the day the schools closed their doors.
The district states in the letter that it declares a financial emergency under Michigan Public Act 436 of 2012. That financial emergency stems partly from state money the district accepted for funding Wolverine Secure Treatment Center, an alternative high school that is no longer in operation. When the state required the district to pay back the $402,000, it was discovered district officials had already spent the money and did not have funds in the coffers to reimburse the state.
This video reports on the closing of the Buena Vista School District.
Offer by Teachers to Work for Free Rejected
The reports that the 27 teachers in Buena Vista met on May 6 after learning the news of the district鈥檚 financial difficulties. The teachers agreed to continue teaching without pay to ensure their students did not have a disruption in their school year. However, that decision was not easy for many of the district teachers who were facing financial challenges. One teacher noted by the Huffington Post was getting ready to send her son to college and wasn鈥檛 sure how his tuition would be paid in light of the district鈥檚 news.
Despite that decision by teachers, reports in a second article that the Buena Vista School District opted to lay off all the teachers in the district and canceled classes at all schools. Jo Ann Nash, president of the local teacher鈥檚 union, told mLive, 鈥淲e voted to continue working. And they voted to lay us off anyway.鈥
Michigan Education Association President Steve Cook, voiced his displeasure with the district鈥檚 decision, saying, 鈥淎side from the time to come up with a solution with the state, the Buena Vista Education Association and the MEA offered up our professional assistance in coming up with a plan that would help lead the district out of deficit. Tonight鈥檚 clear response? Thanks, but no thanks.鈥
The district explained its decision by saying Michigan law requires employers to pay employees for services performed. Although the district voiced appreciation for the teachers鈥 dedication, the district website states that district officials must 鈥渇ollow the law.鈥 states that in addition to losing their paychecks, Buena Vista teachers have lost all of their benefits, including health insurance.
This video reports on the imminent dissolution of the Buena Vista Schools.
Students Left in Limbo
With the sudden closure of all the district schools, more than 400 students in the district are left in limbo. Parents are looking for alternatives in nearby districts to ensure their students can finish the current school year, which is not scheduled to end until June 13. The district has also tried to find another option for students, which included moving students to nearby Saginaw County, according to a separate report in the . However, financial constraints have left district officials looking at a dead end where its students are concerned.
The problem was particularly troublesome for high school seniors in Buena Vista, who were uncertain about their ability to graduate on time. These students are now wondering whether they will get to see any of the rites of passage typically enjoyed by high school seniors 鈥 prom, graduation, and the ability to pursue higher education after high school.
鈥淚t鈥檚 tragic,鈥 Rae鈥橭nna Barabino, this year鈥檚 valedictorian at Buena Vista High School, told the Huffington Post. 鈥淲e have to worry about prom and graduation and ending our year. It鈥檚 very confusing and upsetting. It鈥檚 also heartbreaking.鈥
Barabino added that she plans to attend Eastern Michigan University in the fall to study nursing. Now, she is unsure whether her plans will be able to proceed.
Graduation Passed, but Ceremonies Uncertain
The good news is that Buena Vista district officials have passed a resolution to allow the class of 2013 to graduate, which means their plans after high school will continue. However, that vote did not ensure students would enjoy the year-end celebrations many had been looking forward to for months and even years.
At this point, it is anyone鈥檚 guess what will happen next in the Buena Vista School District. Michigan Governor Rick Snyder has had little comment on the problem at this point other than to say a bailout of the district would 鈥渟et a dangerous precedent.鈥 But many are confident they know where the blame for this education fiasco lies.
鈥淲e will remind [Snyder and other state lawmakers] where the real fault lies,鈥 Cook said at mLive. 鈥淲ith gross mismanagement and misguided priorities on the part of this school district and the state politicians and bureaucrats involved in robbing the education and the future of 400 innocent students.鈥
Questions? Contact us on Facebook. @publicschoolreview
